People who start to discern are often unsure which life they are really pursuing. A desire for priesthood, for religious life, for the diaconate or for Carmel can feel like one question when the lives themselves are different. We have included this account for anyone thinking about discernment, and as something to consider before you write to us. You do not need to have it settled. Bring whatever it raises to the conversation.
The priest in a parish is, most often, a diocesan priest. He lives and works in the world of one diocese. At ordination he promises celibacy and obedience to his bishop, and he belongs to that diocese for life. His priesthood is spent among its parishes, schools, hospitals and prisons. His superior is his bishop. His people are whoever lives inside those boundaries.
Beside him is the permanent deacon, ordained, and ordained to the diaconate rather than to the priesthood. He serves at the altar, preaches, baptises and witnesses marriages, and he can carry the Church into ordinary work. He may be a married man, with a job and a family. Men on the way to priesthood are ordained deacon for a time. The permanent diaconate is a vocation of its own.
A religious belongs first to a community, an order or a congregation, rather than to a territory. He or she takes vows of poverty, chastity and obedience, and lives with brothers or sisters. Where a diocesan priest’s stability is a place, a religious’s stability is the community. The orders are not interchangeable. What distinguishes them is a charism: a gift of the Holy Spirit, given to a founder and handed on, a particular way of living the Gospel. The Carmelites are one such group.
Within that, the forms of life are different again. A monk joins one monastery and stays, and the world comes to him. A friar’s home is his order, not a single house: he may be sent to preach, to pray and to serve wherever the community needs him. A brother is fully vowed to poverty, chastity and obedience, and his calling is that consecrated life itself — the prayer, the community and the work — without ordination to the priesthood. It is a complete vocation, as old as religious life.
Among women the words mark a real difference. A nun takes solemn vows and lives a contemplative life within the enclosure. Her work is to seek the face of God for the whole Church, in silence. An active sister also takes vows and lives in community, and her charism sends her out: to teach, to nurse, to care for the poor, to serve a parish. Each is a whole vocation.
Carmel holds these on one mountain. The friars, priests and brothers, live a contemplative charism in community and carry it into parishes, chaplaincies and retreats. The nuns are the enclosed heart of the Order, holding the Church in prayer. Secular Carmelites, married and single, make promises rather than vows and live the same spirit in the middle of ordinary life. Which of these is yours is rarely settled by a list. It becomes clearer in contact: a chapel, a community, a conversation.